Planning Guide January 9, 2025 8 min read

How to Choose the Right Party Character

Can't decide between Elsa and Moana? Spider-Man or Batman? Our guide helps you pick the perfect character for your celebration.

Princess Elsa interacting with children at a birthday party

Choosing the right party character can feel overwhelming with so many options! This guide walks you through the decision-making process to find the perfect match for your child's celebration.

Step 1: Ask Your Child

This might seem obvious, but it's the most important step! Observe:

  • What do they watch? What shows/movies play on repeat?
  • What do they dress as? For playtime, not just Halloween
  • What do they talk about? Which characters come up in conversation?
  • What toys do they love? Dolls, action figures, stuffed animals

If They Can't Decide...

Some kids want "all of them!" or change their mind daily. In this case:

  • Go with their most consistent favorite over time
  • Consider which character matches the party theme you're planning
  • Book their current favorite (they'll love it in the moment!)
  • Consider a multi-character party if budget allows

Step 2: Consider the Age Group

Ages 1-2 (Babies/Young Toddlers)

  • Best: Mascot characters (soft, huggable)
  • Popular: Mickey Mouse, Bluey
  • Avoid: Scary or intense characters
  • Note: Some babies may be overwhelmed by any character

Ages 3-5 (Preschool)

  • Best: Both mascot and face characters work well
  • Popular: Elsa, Paw Patrol, CoComelon
  • Note: Some kids are shy—let character approach gently

Ages 6-8 (School Age)

  • Best: Face characters for more sophisticated interaction
  • Popular: Superheroes, princesses with activities
  • Note: Kids appreciate character's "performance"

Ages 9+ (Tweens)

  • Consider: May be "too cool" for characters
  • If interested: Superheroes often work
  • Alternative: May prefer other entertainment

Guest Ages Matter Too

If party guests vary widely in age, choose a universally appealing character. Spider-Man, Elsa, and Mickey work across ages. Avoid characters that only appeal to very young kids if older siblings will attend.

Step 3: Match the Venue

Pool/Beach Party

  • Perfect: Moana, Ariel
  • Works: Any character (they stay poolside)

Outdoor Summer Party

  • Best: Face characters (handle heat better than mascots)
  • Consider: Moana, adventure-themed characters

Indoor Venue

  • Best: Any character—all work well indoors
  • Mascots: Perform great in AC environments

Winter Party

  • Perfect: Elsa (ice theme!)
  • Consider: Holiday characters

Step 4: Understand Character Types

Face Characters (Princesses, Superheroes)

Pros:

  • Can speak and have conversations
  • Sing songs from their movies
  • More nuanced interaction
  • Better in hot weather

Best for: Ages 3+, kids who want "real" princess/hero experience

Mascot Characters (Bluey, Mickey, etc.)

Pros:

  • Soft, huggable, approachable
  • Less intimidating for young children
  • Physical play-focused (hugs, dancing)
  • Great for photos

Best for: Ages 1-5, shy kids, first-time character experiences

Browse All Characters

See our full lineup of princesses, superheroes, and mascots!

View Characters

When to Book Multiple Characters

Good Reasons for Multiple Characters

  • Large parties: 25+ kids benefit from multiple characters
  • Character pairs: Elsa + Anna, Mickey + Minnie
  • Mixed interests: Princess + superhero for siblings
  • Long events: 3+ hour parties

Popular Combinations

  • Elsa + Anna (Frozen fans)
  • Spider-Man + Batman (superhero fans)
  • Mickey + Minnie (character fans)
  • Princess + Superhero (sibling parties)

Quick Selection Guide

Situation Recommended
Shy toddlerMascot character (Bluey, Mickey)
Princess-obsessedTheir favorite princess
Action-lovingSpider-Man, superheroes
Pool partyMoana, Ariel
Mixed ages/gendersMickey, Bluey, Spider-Man
First birthdayMickey, Minnie, mascots

Final Thoughts

The "right" character is the one your child loves most. Don't overthink it—if they're obsessed with Elsa, book Elsa. If they want Spider-Man at their princess-themed party, that's okay too! The magic comes from seeing their favorite character in person, regardless of whether it "matches" perfectly.

Still not sure? Contact us—we're happy to help you choose!

Frequently Asked Questions

What if my child changes their mind after booking?

Contact us as soon as possible! We can often accommodate character changes with enough notice. This is common with young children whose favorites change frequently.

Can I book a character my child hasn't seen/doesn't know?

We don't recommend it. The magic works because children KNOW and LOVE the character. A surprise character they don't recognize loses much of the impact.

Characters.io Team

Characters.io Party Planning Team

Helping families choose perfect characters since 2015.

Find Your Character